The World’s Leading Microsoft .NET Magazine
   
 
The .NET Addict's Blog

My Top Tags

                                                           

My RSS Feeds








I heart FeedBurner

Latest Diggs - Programming

Computers Blogs - Blog Top Sites

Site Hits

Total: 2,817,121
since: 19 Jan 2005

DRM Done Right: Renting iTunes Movies and the Family Guy Blue Harvest DVD

posted Sat 19 Jan 08

As everyone probably knows after watching the Macworld 2008 keynote, the newest version of iTunes both for PCs/Macs and for the iPhone supports movie rentals. Eager to try this out (especially since I had some store credit left over from Christmas), I went to iTunes and I rented the latest Die Hard movie.

There were a couple of errors I received when attempting to rent the movie, but admittedly it was a Friday night and movie rentals is a new thing for the iTunes store - I'm pretty sure they were getting overloaded with rental requests. After only about 3 or 4 retries, I got the rental to fire off. The movie, a full-size DVD (non-HD), took about 30 minutes to download. Once downloaded, it informed me that I had 30 days to start watching the movie, and 24 hours to watch the movie.

As it turns out, you can watch the movie over and over again for as many times as you like during the 24 hour period. The entire experience was very, very seamless. Oh, and did I mention that I watched it once on my Macbook Pro and once on the iPhone? I love having movies on the go and the iPhone, despite the small form factor, is quite a good movie playing device.

There is only one thing that Apple needs to do in order to make the iTunes rental experience become the dominating force in movie rentals today... subscriptions. They should figure out what Netflix charges for its streamed rentals per month, and they should charge $1 less. That would be a clincher for sure. Then I wouldn't have to ponder whether I want to spend $4 on a given movie, if I'm paying monthly to download whatever movies I like.

On to Family Guy : Blue Harvest. I bought the DVD in the store, brought it home and popped the second DVD into the Macbook Pro's optical drive. I double-clicked the iTunes icon, entered the serial number, and about 40 seconds later I had a complete digital copy of the movie sitting in my iTunes library.

This is how movies should be done. Period. What most movie studios don't realize is that people like me, and average Joes all over the country have been positively begging for a reason to buy their movies. People don't actually want to pirate the movies, they want their digital movies to be brain-dead-simple and convenient. The family guy digital copy was ridiculously convenient. I can now copy that movie to the iPhone, I can drag it into popcorn and burn a DVD with that 40 minute video clip and maybe 1 or 2 other Family Guy episodes and make my own family guy mix DVD. I can absolutely guarantee that if more movies come with digital copies in the box, people will buy more boxed movies instead of pirating them. DRM is an annoyance that serves to piss off regular consumers and simply slow down hackers. If you want to please regular consumers, give me DRM-free, dead-simple and convenient movies that I can copy to whatever device I want, and I will purchase more movies.

If people keep pulling the same old bullshit where CDs are "enhanced" with extra crap so that they cannot be ripped into iTunes or Windows Media Player - I will stop buying CDs. The formula is really simple:

- Convenient and unhindered access to media that you legitimately purchased == people buy more stuff.

- Annoying pain in the ass jumping through hoops and arbitrary security that usually backfires on legitimate owners == people will pirate more stuff.

I'm looking forward to watching Family Guy : Blue Harvest on my iPhone and renting new releases from iTunes instead of my cable company. 

tags:                

links: digg this    del.icio.us    technorati    reddit




1. Nic Wise left...
Sun 20 Jan 08 2:43 am :: http://www.fastchicken.co.nz/blog/

"DRM is an annoyance that serves to piss off regular consumers and simply slow down hackers. "

Having been to Bali and Thailand recently, I'd say that "slow down" isn't even the case. It slows them down ONCE ('cos once it's cracked or extracted, it's all over), and pisses off regular people EVERY TIME they use it.

Thanks for the post - was a good read. We are on our second rental now (woot), having watched more movies this way thru itunes in 2 days than we did in 24 months with the buy-it-delete-it model :) Takes around 2 hours for me to download (I'm in the UK with a US itunes account), but thats fine - get it the night before, and we are good to go.

Now, I wonder when the Family Guy DVD is coming out here. I never thought of buying it, to be honest, but now I think I might.... :) Or, I'll just get it off iTunes :)

Between the subscriptions and season passes, the only stuff I "pirate" (torrent) now is stuff I can't get on iTunes - Heroes being an obvious one. Apple/NBC puts that back online, and I'm good to go.

So, hows the .NET / MAC dev book coming along (says a fellow .NET dev (and ex-MVP) with a Mac, but no big desire to learn Objective-C _again_ :) )?


2. Kevin Hoffman left...
Sun 20 Jan 08 10:42 am

If there is a .NET/Cocoa book being written, it's being written without me completing it. I wrote the first four chapters of the book and then a mutual decision was reached to stop the project. I like giving the code samples away on the blog better anyway :)

I totally agree about Heroes. That's why I'm looking forward to using Popcorn to take Heroes off my TiVo and put it on my iPhone without iTunes. Damn NBC. Bunch of whiners. The took Stargate off of iTunes also.


3. John Baldwin left...
Mon 21 Jan 08 1:59 am

Bummer about the book. I was looking forward to a comparison of the two frameworks. At least there's your blog.


4. David Orriss Jr left...
Tue 05 Feb 08 3:51 pm :: http://www.codethought.com/blog

I LOVED the Blue Harvest Digital Copy. That was so convenient all I could do during the entire 3 minutes I was downloading and moving BH to my iPod was go "oh wow.. it can't be this easy". Without that I'd have to - circumvent copy protection - rip to my harddrive - turn it into something iPod-friendly with Handbrake-etc etc etc.

Fox had it right with that. Kudos to them.


5. Erb left...
Wed 06 Feb 08 3:17 pm

Making it simple is exactly correct. Even without DRM, if making digital copies is not brain-dead simple, then the non-techy consumers will continue to use P2P networks to get their digital entertainment because it makes it easy to get it onto their MP3 or video player.


Tag Related Posts

Apple drops the iPhone NDA for Released Software

Wed 01 Oct 08 3:54 P GMT-05
tags:          

Cappuccino, Objective-J, and You

Wed 10 Sep 08 6:14 P GMT-05

So I'm in the LA Times ;)

Wed 27 Aug 08 2:51 P GMT-05
tags:                  

MobileMe vs. Live Mesh Throwdown - Round 1

Wed 16 Jul 08 10:33 A GMT-05

Building Model Classes in C# and Cocoa

Sun 15 Jun 08 3:13 P GMT-05
tags:            

MobileMe vs. Live Mesh - Round 1

Wed 11 Jun 08 12:20 A GMT-05

My Macbook Air is masculine, dammit!

Mon 17 Mar 08 6:59 P GMT-05
tags:          

iPhone Underrated as a Gaming Device?

Fri 14 Mar 08 1:50 P GMT-05
tags:        

My take on the iPhone SDK

Sat 08 Mar 08 1:39 P GMT-05

Jobs says "not likely" to Flash on the iPhone

Thu 06 Mar 08 1:39 A GMT-05
tags:          

My Macbook Air Review

Sun 02 Mar 08 4:20 P GMT-05

iPhone Roadmap March 6th

Fri 29 Feb 08 10:41 P GMT-05
tags:        

Video of the Macbook Air in Action

Wed 20 Feb 08 3:04 P GMT-05

Macbook Airはきれいですよ!

Sun 17 Feb 08 2:38 A GMT-05

Why is O'Reilly Condoning iPhone Hacking?

Mon 11 Feb 08 3:55 P GMT-05

Evaluating my next laptop purchase

Wed 06 Feb 08 8:40 P GMT-05

The iPhone SDK key has been leaked! Oh Noez!!!1

Tue 29 Jan 08 11:36 A GMT-05
tags:        

Why Geeks just don't "get" the Macbook Air

Thu 17 Jan 08 2:30 P GMT-05

Popcorn + TiVo + Macbook Pro + iPhone == Hell Yeah!

Tue 15 Jan 08 3:11 P GMT-05
tags:          

How my ADC membership changed my life

Mon 31 Dec 07 3:57 P GMT-05
tags:      

Leopard Code Sample : Sprinkling in some Bonjour

Tue 27 Nov 07 2:32 P GMT-05
tags:        

Leopard Sample: A Bound NSCollectionView

Mon 29 Oct 07 1:41 A GMT-05

Leopard is out - let the code samples begin!

Fri 26 Oct 07 10:09 A GMT-05
tags:          

My life is complete : iPhone SDK is CONFIRMED.

Wed 17 Oct 07 6:38 P GMT-05
tags:          

Leopard Shipping October 26th!!

Tue 16 Oct 07 4:59 P GMT-05
tags:        

My iPhone Review

Mon 23 Jul 07 1:09 P GMT-05
tags:        

Microsoft Codename Acropolis - Unwrapped

Wed 20 Jun 07 3:22 P GMT-05
tags:              

I'm going to be on TV (sort of)

Sat 02 Jun 07 12:19 P GMT-05
tags:              

Exploring the Delegate Design Pattern

Mon 14 May 07 6:30 P GMT-05

Core Data - Almost too Easy?

Wed 18 Apr 07 2:23 P GMT-05

An experience with the Leopard beta

Mon 26 Mar 07 7:45 P GMT-05
tags:                

WPF Bindings == WTF Bindings?

Mon 12 Mar 07 6:31 P GMT-05

Objective-C 2.0 - Programming for wimps?

Wed 31 Jan 07 6:18 P GMT-05
tags:              

Mac OS X Leopard Developer Preview

Tue 09 Jan 07 1:58 P GMT-05
tags:      

White and Nerdy - My new Anthem

Fri 06 Oct 06 3:13 P GMT-05
tags: