The World’s Leading Microsoft .NET Magazine
   
 
The .NET Addict's Blog

My Top Tags

                                                           

My RSS Feeds








Latest Diggs - Programming

Internet Blogs - Blog Top Sites

Site Hits

Total: 2,639,104
since: 19 Jan 2005

Concrete example of why the iPhone is better than its competitors

posted Sun 12 Aug 07

If you take a look at the success of the Nintendo Wii, you'll see an innovative device with an incredibly compelling user interaction design (the Wiimote, nunchuck, steering wheels, fitness pads, etc). The device itself has what the industry might actually refer to as "last gen" hardware. The video card is weak relative to the PS3 and Xbox 360, it doesn't come with built-in LAN (though you can buy a LAN/USB adapter for it), it has less memory and less processor power than the PS3 and Xbox 360. Yet, despite these so-called deficiencies, everybody seems to love their Wii, and it's actually gaining a lot of momentum sales-wise while the others are slowing down.

So, let's take a look at the iPhone as a comparison. It's an innovative new device that has some obvious deficiencies in terms of hardware - most notably in the lack of 3G/EVDO support. You can't tether with the thing, and it's missing some core features that a lot of Blackberry folks consider requirements.

So here's my story:

Last night, I pulled up to a red light caused by a New Jersey Transit train passing in front of me. Keep in mind that this isn't some 100-car giant coal-loader that takes 25 minutes to pass through like they've got out in the midwest (those things are AWFUL... try sitting through that crap on a hot 95+ degree day!), these trains take 90 seconds to get in and out of an intersection...TOPS. With my window down at the red light, I could smell some nearby chinese food. I knew I was coming back that way after running some errands, so I flipped out the iPhone and tapped in "chinese" and then the name of my town into the iPhone's "maps" feature. The third item down was the name of the chinese restaurant across the street from me. I tapped it, flicked down and then tapped "Create new contact". I put the phone away and had about 30 more seconds left before the train went and the light went green.

A few minutes later at another store while waiting for something, I made a call to the chinese restaurant and ordered my food.

So, the point of the story isn't that I like chinese food (I do, but that's not the point...). The point of the story is that despite being somewhat deficient in terms of hardware relative to some enterprise phones, this thing is designed to make my life easier. I have owned many smart phones, most of which ran Windows Mobile in one way, shape or form. I even had a "local restaurants" application specifically for my last smart phone that I used a few times. I was NEVER able to accomplish ANYTHING in 90 seconds. So, at this point I don't care that EDGE is slow - I was able to do what I needed to do on the EDGE network in 90 seconds while waiting for a train to pass - I wasn't able to do that with the fastest EVDO tetherable enterprise-class Smart Phone on the market.

Vegetable egg rolls never tasted so good...

tags:    

links: digg this    del.icio.us    technorati    reddit




1. James Gregurich left...
Sun 12 Aug 07 8:00 pm

in my 2.5 years of living in PA, I can't ever recall seeing a commuter train intersect a street in the northeast. They were aways overhead or sunken below the roads. Now, I guess I can no longer brag on the east coast to west coast public transit riders. :)


2. Kevin Hoffman left...
Sun 12 Aug 07 9:57 pm

Heh, in most of the larger areas the trains are raised or sunken, but in smaller towns out near the Jersey coast, the trains run at street level. There are actually a couple of stops where there isn't even a platform, the train just deposits people literally 50 feet from neaby businesses and parking lots.


3. Juan T. left...
Tue 14 Aug 07 11:47 am

In my opinion, this is exactly why the iPhone is worth every cent. I have done similar things with it with such great ease that is a pleasure. At a friend's backyard I ordered tickets for a concert. When driving anywhere without directions I am not longer lost. I can find any word I don't know the definition for or almost any little piece of information I need. Of all my friends with other smart phone, I am the one that uses the phone the most. I think you hit the mark with your example (at least for me). I enjoyed reading it. Thanks!


4. Kevin Hoffman left...
Tue 14 Aug 07 12:10 pm

Exactly. The point is that the iPhone may not be the fastest, or the most powerful, or the phone with the MOST utilities. However, it is the single most useful portable device I have ever owned, and it has actually come in _handy_ multiple times, unlike all my other so-called smart phones which remained little more than novelties throughout their lifetimes.


5. Erb left...
Mon 20 Aug 07 11:07 am

(Re WII): LAN? LAN??? Who uses LAN anymore?


6. Kevin Hoffman left...
Mon 20 Aug 07 11:41 am

Erb: Just about everyone uses LAN. Just because you've got WiFi in your house doesn't necessarily mean that you're totally unplugged. My Xbox 360, Printer, and iMac are all plugged into the LAN. The only WiFi-only devices are my laptops and the iPhone, and the Wii (the Wii is only WiFi because I don't have the LAN adapter ... mostly because it lacks sufficient multiplayer gaming to convince me I need it.. yet).


Tag Related Posts

So I'm in the LA Times ;)

Wed 27 Aug 08 2:51 P GMT-05
tags:                  

MobileMe vs. Live Mesh Throwdown - Round 1

Wed 16 Jul 08 10:33 A GMT-05

Building Model Classes in C# and Cocoa

Sun 15 Jun 08 3:13 P GMT-05
tags:            

MobileMe vs. Live Mesh - Round 1

Wed 11 Jun 08 12:20 A GMT-05

My Macbook Air is masculine, dammit!

Mon 17 Mar 08 6:59 P GMT-05
tags:          

iPhone Developer Summit

Sun 16 Mar 08 8:39 P GMT-05

iPhone Underrated as a Gaming Device?

Fri 14 Mar 08 1:50 P GMT-05
tags:        

My take on the iPhone SDK

Sat 08 Mar 08 1:39 P GMT-05

Jobs says "not likely" to Flash on the iPhone

Thu 06 Mar 08 1:39 A GMT-05
tags:          

My Macbook Air Review

Sun 02 Mar 08 4:20 P GMT-05

iPhone Roadmap March 6th

Fri 29 Feb 08 10:41 P GMT-05
tags:        

Video of the Macbook Air in Action

Wed 20 Feb 08 3:04 P GMT-05

Macbook Airはきれいですよ!

Sun 17 Feb 08 2:38 A GMT-05

Why is O'Reilly Condoning iPhone Hacking?

Mon 11 Feb 08 3:55 P GMT-05

Evaluating my next laptop purchase

Wed 06 Feb 08 8:40 P GMT-05

The iPhone SDK key has been leaked! Oh Noez!!!1

Tue 29 Jan 08 11:36 A GMT-05
tags:        

Why Geeks just don't "get" the Macbook Air

Thu 17 Jan 08 2:30 P GMT-05

Popcorn + TiVo + Macbook Pro + iPhone == Hell Yeah!

Tue 15 Jan 08 3:11 P GMT-05
tags:          

How my ADC membership changed my life

Mon 31 Dec 07 3:57 P GMT-05
tags:      

Leopard Code Sample : Sprinkling in some Bonjour

Tue 27 Nov 07 2:32 P GMT-05
tags:        

Celebrity Death Match: iPhone vs. gPhone

Tue 06 Nov 07 1:52 A GMT-05
tags:    

Leopard Sample: A Bound NSCollectionView

Mon 29 Oct 07 1:41 A GMT-05

Leopard is out - let the code samples begin!

Fri 26 Oct 07 10:09 A GMT-05
tags:          

My life is complete : iPhone SDK is CONFIRMED.

Wed 17 Oct 07 6:38 P GMT-05
tags:          

Leopard Shipping October 26th!!

Tue 16 Oct 07 4:59 P GMT-05
tags:        

Editorial : My thoughts on iPhone Hacking

Tue 25 Sep 07 6:10 P GMT-05
tags:      

$4800 iPhone Bill for International Data Roaming

Mon 10 Sep 07 1:15 P GMT-05
tags:    

iPhone Apps are now also iPod Touch Apps

Sat 08 Sep 07 7:33 P GMT-05
tags:    

Using the iPhone Keyboard

Fri 31 Aug 07 2:08 P GMT-05
tags:      

Meebo on my iPhone - a useable IM client!

Tue 24 Jul 07 2:56 P GMT-05
tags:    

My iPhone Review

Mon 23 Jul 07 1:09 P GMT-05
tags:        

Wil Shipley Discusses the lack of iPhone SDK

Mon 09 Jul 07 1:50 P GMT-05
tags:    

OMFGWTF iPhonez0rz!!1!one!!

Fri 29 Jun 07 5:45 P GMT-05
tags:  

Microsoft Codename Acropolis - Unwrapped

Wed 20 Jun 07 3:22 P GMT-05
tags:              

Exploring the Delegate Design Pattern

Mon 14 May 07 6:30 P GMT-05

Core Data - Almost too Easy?

Wed 18 Apr 07 2:23 P GMT-05

An experience with the Leopard beta

Mon 26 Mar 07 7:45 P GMT-05
tags:                

WPF Bindings == WTF Bindings?

Mon 12 Mar 07 6:31 P GMT-05

Objective-C 2.0 - Programming for wimps?

Wed 31 Jan 07 6:18 P GMT-05
tags:              

Mac OS X Leopard Developer Preview

Tue 09 Jan 07 1:58 P GMT-05
tags: